Why Is My Insulation Not Working? Common Problems & Solutions
You crank the heat and still need three blankets. You blast the AC and your second floor still feels like the inside of a bread oven. Meanwhile, your energy bill looks like a car payment.
So you’re asking: "What the heck is going on? I have insulation. Why isn't it working?"
Good question. Insulation should keep your home comfortable year-round. But just having it doesn’t mean it’s doing its job. Like anything else in a house, it can be installed wrong, wear out, or just not be the right fit for where you live.
Let’s break down the most common reasons insulation underperforms—and how to fix them before winter (or summer) bites back.
1. Not Enough Insulation (a.k.a. Your R-Value’s on Life Support)
The problem: You might have insulation, but not enough of it. It’s like wearing a windbreaker in January—technically clothing, but not keeping you warm.
Why it matters: Insulation works by resisting heat transfer. Not enough R-value = heat leaks out in winter, seeps in during summer.
The fix:
Here’s what Connecticut homes should have:
- Attic: R-49 to R-60
- Walls: R-13 to R-21
- Floors: R-25 to R-30
- Basements/Crawl Spaces: R-10 to R-19
If you’re way below those numbers, it’s time to bulk up. We recommend blown-in cellulose insulation—it packs tighter, performs better, and actually stays where it’s supposed to.
2. Your Insulation’s Old and Saggy
The problem: Insulation doesn’t last forever. Over time, it compresses, shifts, settles—or just plain gives up.
Why it matters:
- Fiberglass batts can slump or fall out of place.
- Older blown-in fiberglass settles like sand in an hourglass.
- Even old cellulose can sag if it was installed before modern treatments.
The fix:
Have your attic checked. If your insulation looks like a pancake instead of a fluffy cake, it’s not doing much. We typically top off or replace with modern cellulose—it stays in place better and keeps your R-value high.
3. You’ve Got Air Leaks Everywhere
The problem: Even the best insulation can’t stop air that’s sneaking around it. Drafts around windows, doors, can lights, attic hatches—these are the usual suspects.
Why it matters:
- In winter: warm air escapes, cold air creeps in.
- In summer: your cooled air leaks out like a deflating balloon.
The fix:
- Weatherstrip doors and windows
- Seal attic penetrations before insulating
- Use spray foam or rigid foam to block bigger gaps (pipes, vents, etc.)
- Pro tip: Never insulate before you air seal. That’s just putting a blanket over a broken window.
4. Moisture Is Wrecking Your Insulation
The problem: If your attic or basement has poor ventilation, leaks, or condensation, your insulation’s probably getting soggy.
Why it matters:
- Wet fiberglass is basically useless.
- Spray foam can trap moisture—mold loves that.
- Moisture flattens insulation and kills your R-value.
The fix:
- Choose cellulose—it handles moisture better than fiberglass.
- Improve attic or crawl space ventilation.
- Fix any roof leaks, flashing gaps, or foundation cracks ASAP.
5. It Was Installed Like a Weekend DIY Project (a bad one)
The problem: We see this all the time—gaps, compressions, missed spots. Doesn’t matter how good the material is if it’s not installed right.
Why it matters:
- Gaps = heat loss
- Compressed batts = reduced R-value
- No air sealing = insulation gets bypassed completely
The fix:
- Hire pros (like us). Seriously. It matters.
- We blow in dense-pack cellulose that fills every nook, cranny, and gap.
- We don’t just dump insulation and leave—we air seal first, every time.
6. Rodents Turned Your Attic into an Airbnb
The problem: Mice, squirrels, and raccoons love insulation. It’s warm, it’s soft, and they don’t care if it’s supposed to keep your energy bills low.
Why it matters:
- They tear up your insulation
- Their waste contaminates it
- They create airflow gaps and invite mold
The fix:
- Seal up entry points (soffits, vents, roof lines)
- Use borate-treated cellulose, which pests hate
- Remove and replace any contaminated insulation
7. You Picked the Wrong Type of Insulation
The problem: Not all insulation is built for New England. What works in Arizona doesn’t always work here.
Why it matters:
- Fiberglass batts leak air and settle
- Spray foam can trap moisture and costs a fortune to fix if things go south
- Rigid foam works in basements, but not great in attics
The fix:
Go with blown-in cellulose for most applications. It checks all the boxes:
- High R-value
- Pest-resistant
- Moisture-tolerant
- Fills every gap
- Made for our climate
How We Can Help (Without the Sales Fluff)
At Nealon Insulation, we’ve been fixing insulation problems since bell bottoms were a thing (1977, to be exact). Whether your attic needs a full rehab or just a tune-up, we know what works in Connecticut homes.
✅ Free insulation inspections
✅ Specialists in blown-in cellulose
✅ EnergizeCT rebates to help you save
✅ No pressure—just straight answers
Bottom line: If your insulation isn’t working, there’s always a reason. Let’s find it—and fix it right.
📞 Give us a call or book a free inspection. We’ll get your home feeling like home again.
Related Articles
How Much Money Will I Really Save by Upgrading my Insulation?
Let’s be honest—insulation isn’t sexy. It’s not something you show off to your neighbors. It’s not your renovated Kitchen with marble finishing or a beautiful new stone deck with a built in grill and smoker.
Let’s be honest—insulation isn’t sexy. It’s not something you show off to your neighbors. It’s not your renovated Kitchen with marble finishing or a beautiful new stone deck with a built in grill and smoker.
No one’s coming over to crack open beers and admire the craftsmanship… “Wow, check out that R-49 blown cellulose! There’s no lumps or anything!”
But… if you own a home in Connecticut, insulation might be the most boring way to save yourself the most money. You won’t get oooh’s and aaah’s but you will get lower energy bills, a more comfortable home, and fewer fights over the thermostat.
But I know what you’re now asking yourself… how much can I really save? How long does insulation take to pay for itself?
🥁🥁🥁
The Short Answer: 2 to 5 Years…
The Even Shorter Answer: It depends! But it does works
But definitely don’t take my word for it. What do I know, I’ve only been doing this for 40 years… And I’ve been told I’m biased or something…
Let’s see what the Research Says
According to the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and Energize CT, insulation and air sealing will shave 15–30% off your heating and cooling bills. In Connecticut, where winters are long and heating oil is basically liquid gold, that adds up!
- The average Connecticut household spends around $2,000 per year on heating and cooling combined (source: EIA.gov).
- So let’s do some quick math!
- If you saved 20% on your heating and cooling bills that’s $400/year back in your pocket.
- If your insulation project costs around ~$2,000 that’s about a 5 year payback
- If you save closer to 30%...that’s less than a three and a half year payback
- After that it’s just continuous money in your pocket for the next 25-30 years until you need another upgrade
But like I said before… it depends!
Not to brag or anything but we’ve upgraded homes in which the payback period was fewer than 2 years!
Add in Connecticut’s Home Energy Solutions program, and it gets better. The program can often cover up to 75% of the cost through rebates and incentives.
Facts, Myths, and We-Just-Don’t-Know
There’s a lot of information floating around out there...let’s break it down.
✅ Facts
- Insulation reduces energy bills.
- This is backed by the DOE, ENERGY STAR, and pretty much anyone who’s upgraded their insulation and compared their before and after their utility bill afterward.
- This is backed by the DOE, ENERGY STAR, and pretty much anyone who’s upgraded their insulation and compared their before and after their utility bill afterward.
- Air sealing matters. A lot.
- Think of it like this: insulation is your sweater. Air sealing is zipping up your jacket. Both are good. Together, they’re great.
- Think of it like this: insulation is your sweater. Air sealing is zipping up your jacket. Both are good. Together, they’re great.
- Rebates are available.
- Older homes in CT are often wildly under-insulated.
- Especially if they were built before 1980. Some wall cavities are literally empty.
- Especially if they were built before 1980. Some wall cavities are literally empty.
❌ Myths
- “Insulation only helps me in the winter.”
- Nope. It helps in summer too by keeping heat out and ensuring more efficient AC use. Ever been in an attic in July? If so, you get it.
- Nope. It helps in summer too by keeping heat out and ensuring more efficient AC use. Ever been in an attic in July? If so, you get it.
- “If I have insulation, I’m good.”
- Maybe. But maybe not. A lot of homes have insulation that’s:
- Just not enough
- Poorly installed
- Degraded over time
- Maybe. But maybe not. A lot of homes have insulation that’s:
- “It’s too expensive to be worth it.”
- With rebates and long-term savings, insulation’s one of the few home upgrades that pays for itself—and then keeps paying.
- With rebates and long-term savings, insulation’s one of the few home upgrades that pays for itself—and then keeps paying.
🤷♂️ We Just Don’t Know
- Exactly how fast your home will pay it back.
- We need to see the place. Every home is different. We’ll look at square footage, current insulation levels, energy bills, and then we can estimate savings and rebates.
- We need to see the place. Every home is different. We’ll look at square footage, current insulation levels, energy bills, and then we can estimate savings and rebates.
- How much longer Connecticut winters will get.
- Between polar vortexes and mild Decembers, who knows. But insulation helps regardless.
- Between polar vortexes and mild Decembers, who knows. But insulation helps regardless.
- Why builders didn’t insulate better in the '60s and '70s.
- Your guess is as good as ours. Maybe they just loved single-pane windows and cold feet.
- Your guess is as good as ours. Maybe they just loved single-pane windows and cold feet.
Final Thoughts
Insulation’s not flashy. It’s not fun to talk about at parties (...actually it is for us). But in terms of bang-for-your-buck, it’s one of the best home improvements you can invest in.
Here’s what you get:
- Real savings
- Real comfort
- A more efficient, quieter, and healthier home
If you’re in Connecticut, you’ve got access to generous incentives. We’ll even help you apply for them. So if your house is cold, drafty, or your energy bills are making you sweat—get in touch.
👉 Get in touch with Nealon Insulation. We’ll take a look, give you honest feedback, and let you know if it makes sense. No pressure. No BS. Just real talk, real results, and real insulation.
Why Does Insulation Lower Your Energy Bill?
Let’s start with this: insulation isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s one of the most cost-effective ways to cut down on your energy bills year-round. Whether you’re battling a New England nor’easter or a brutal summer heatwave, your insulation is doing the quiet, thankless job of keeping conditioned air where it belongs: inside your home.
Let’s start with this: insulation isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s one of the most cost-effective ways to cut down on your energy bills year-round. Whether you’re battling a New England nor’easter or a brutal summer heatwave, your insulation is doing the quiet, thankless job of keeping conditioned air where it belongs: inside your home.
But how does it actually save you money? Let’s break it down.
1. Insulation Slows Down Heat Transfer
Heat moves in and out of your house constantly—through walls, ceilings, floors, and anywhere it finds a weak spot. This process is called heat transfer, and without good insulation, your home is bleeding energy like a sieve. In winter, warm air escapes. In summer, heat pours in. Insulation acts like a barrier, slowing that process down so your HVAC system doesn’t have to work overtime to keep up.
Less work for your furnace or AC = less energy used = lower utility bills.
2. Insulation Keeps Temperatures Stable
Ever notice how some rooms feel freezing while others are sweltering? That’s usually a sign of poor insulation or air leaks. Ideally, rooms in the same house shouldn’t differ by more than 2–3°F. If you're seeing 5 degrees or more between rooms, it’s a red flag—your home likely has insulation gaps or airflow issues.
When you insulate properly—especially your attic, walls, and basement—you even out those swings and stop playing thermostat whack-a-mole. Want to layer your savings? Combine good insulation with simple, low-cost hacks to stay warm in winter—like these 10 free or cheap ways to stay warm.
3. It Reduces HVAC Runtime
Your heating and cooling systems cycle on and off all day. But the better your home holds its temperature, the less often those systems need to run. Over time, this adds up to serious savings—not just on energy, but also on maintenance and equipment lifespan. Well-insulated homes put less wear and tear on HVAC units, meaning fewer breakdowns and a longer system life.
4. It's a One-Time Investment That Pays Off For Years
Insulation isn’t a band-aid fix—it’s a long-term upgrade. Whether you’re using spray foam, batts, or blown-in cellulose, you’re making a one-time investment that keeps paying you back every month.
And if you’re looking to insulate finished walls without tearing everything apart, we’ve got a method for that too. It’s called drill and plug, and it lets us dense-pack cellulose insulation from the outside of your home—sealing up energy loss while leaving everything looking untouched. It’s one of our go-to moves for older homes with empty wall cavities.
The Bottom Line
If your energy bills are creeping higher and your home still doesn’t feel comfortable, your insulation might be the culprit. Fixing it won’t just make your house cozier—it’ll put money back in your pocket every single month.
Want to see what better insulation could do for your home?
👉 Get in touch with Nealon Insulation. We’ll take a look, give it to you straight, and help you lower your bills the smart way.
Why Is Air Sealing Important?
Most people think insulation is the whole game when it comes to making a home energy-efficient. It’s a big part, sure—but if your house is leaking air like a drafty old barn, insulation alone isn’t going to cut it. That’s where air sealing comes in.
Most people think insulation is the whole game when it comes to making a home energy-efficient. It’s a big part, sure—but if your house is leaking air like a drafty old barn, insulation alone isn’t going to cut it. That’s where air sealing comes in.
Think of insulation like a warm winter coat. Now imagine that coat has the zipper wide open and the wind’s whipping through. Not so cozy, right? Air sealing is the zipper. It keeps the conditioned air inside where it belongs—and the outside air out.
What Is Air Sealing?
Air sealing is the process of closing up all the tiny gaps, cracks, and holes in your home’s building envelope. These leaks might be around windows, doors, plumbing penetrations, attic hatches, recessed lights, or even your foundation. You don’t see them—but your energy bill sure feels them.
If you’ve ever walked into a room and it feels 10 degrees colder than the rest of the house, chances are you’ve got air leaks. Same goes for musty smells, moisture problems, or wild swings in your heating and cooling bills.
Why Air Sealing Matters
💸 Lower Energy Bills
Air leaks are one of the biggest causes of energy loss in the average home. Heated or cooled air escapes through those gaps, and your HVAC system has to work harder (and burn more money) to keep up. Air sealing can cut heating and cooling costs by up to 20% in some homes.
Want to understand how heat actually escapes your house? Check out our blog on How Does My Home Lose or Gain Heat?
🌡️ More Consistent Temperatures
Ever notice that one room is always too hot in the summer or freezing in the winter? Air leaks are usually to blame. When you seal those gaps, airflow becomes controlled and consistent—no more temperature rollercoasters from room to room.
It’s especially important in the attic—one of the biggest culprits for leaks.
Our blog on blown-in insulation can help you identify the right insulation for your attic.
💧 Moisture Control
Air leaks don’t just move air—they move moisture. In the winter, warm indoor air rises and escapes through cracks in the attic. That moisture-laden air hits cold surfaces and condenses, which can lead to mold, mildew, and rot. Air sealing helps keep moisture where it belongs—and keeps your home healthier.
🧊 Works Hand-in-Hand with Insulation
Insulation slows down the transfer of heat, but it can’t stop moving air. That’s why insulation without air sealing is like buying an expensive cooler with the lid cracked open. You need both.
If your home feels drafty or your bills are creeping up, it could be a sign your insulation isn’t pulling its weight either. Here’s How to Tell If Your Home Is Under-Insulated
What’s the Air Sealing Process Actually Like?
Glad you asked.
Before we blow in any cellulose, we suit up and hunt down the leaks. Because once you’ve got 14 inches of fluffy insulation in the attic, going back to plug those gaps is like diving into a ball pit with a caulk gun—only sweatier and way less fun. Unless you enjoy spelunking through cellulose, seal it first.
🔧 What We Use
Our go-to is polyurethane insulating foam applied with a standard foam gun. It expands to fill cracks, cures fast, and sticks like a champ. Around wiring, pipes, light fixtures, and top plates? That’s where it shines.
And in basements—especially along the sill plate—we break out the big guns: rodent-resistant foam. This stuff is dense, durable, and keeps out everything from cold drafts to overly curious critters.
🔍 Where We Look
In the Attic:
- Gaps between drywall and top plates
- Around recessed lights and light fixtures
- Plumbing stacks
- HVAC duct penetrations
- Chimney chases
- Attic hatches
In the Basement or Crawlspace:
- All along the perimeter sill and rim joists
- Plumbing, electrical, and dryer vent exits
- Gaps where concrete meets wood framing
These are the usual suspects. Seal them up and you’re halfway to a tighter, more efficient home.
Ready to Seal Up Your Home?
At Nealon Insulation, we don’t just stuff walls with insulation and call it a day. We take a full-building approach, starting with air sealing the key trouble spots. It’s one of the best bang-for-your-buck upgrades you can make to improve comfort, cut energy bills, and keep your home protected year-round.
👉 Contact Nealon Insulation to schedule an energy assessment and see where your home is leaking energy. We’ll get you zipped up tight.
Let's Work Together
Ready to transform your home into an energy-efficient haven? Schedule your free energy assessment today and experience the Nealon difference for yourself.